At PennyVerse.info, we specialize in uncovering hidden treasures in everyday pocket change. This comprehensive guide will show you:
Recent auction sales of rare Bicentennial Quarters
How to identify key errors (with detailed images & descriptions)
The most valuable missing or misprinted details
Step-by-step instructions for selling your coin
The best places to sell for maximum profit
Let’s explore the fascinating world of Bicentennial Quarter errors and discover if yours is a rare find!
1. Recent Sales: How Much Are These Error Coins Worth?
Before examining your coin, let’s look at real-world sales to understand its potential value.
Auction Records & Verified Sales
- $1,800 – A double-struck Bicentennial Quarter sold at Heritage Auctions in 2023
- $950 – A major “cud error” (large raised blob near Washington’s neck) sold on eBay in early 2024
- $650 – A “missing letters” error (incomplete “E PLURIBUS UNUM”) sold in a private coin forum sale
- $300+ – Quarters with an extra drumstick (third stick in drummer’s hand) sold in Facebook collector groups
Why Are These Errors Valuable?
- Extremely low mintage – Many errors were caught early and destroyed
- High demand – Bicentennial coins are highly collectible
- Unique visual appeal – Errors make coins stand out in collections
Pro Tip: If your coin has multiple errors (like a cud + extra drumstick), its value could multiply!
2. How to Spot a Valuable Bicentennial Quarter Error
Now, let’s break down exactly what to look for on your coin.
A. The “Blob on Washington’s Face” (Cud Error)
- What it looks like: A raised, irregular lump of metal (not a scratch or dent)
- Where to check: Near Washington’s cheek, neck, or hair
- Why it’s valuable: Caused by a broken die piece
- How to confirm: Tilt the coin under light—if the blob is smooth and metallic, it’s likely a cud
B. “E PLURIBUS UNION” (Misspelled Motto Error)
- What it looks like: Should read “E PLURIBUS UNUM”—if it says “UNION,” it’s a major error
- Why it’s valuable: Indicates a die engraving mistake
- How to check: Use a 10x magnifier to confirm the letters
C. Extra Drumstick (3rd Stick in Drummer’s Hand)
- What it looks like: The drummer should have two sticks—a third is an error
- Why it’s valuable: Could be a die gouge or doubled strike
- How to confirm: Compare to a normal Bicentennial Quarter
D. Weak or Missing Letters (Filled Die Error)
- What it looks like: Parts of “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” appear faint or missing
- Why it’s valuable: Caused by debris clogging the die
- How to check: Look for weak/missing letters, especially “A,” “S,” or “E”
3. The Most Valuable Errors (Ranked)
Not all errors are equal. Here’s a ranking of the most valuable flaws:
| Error Type | Rarity (1-10) | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| “E PLURIBUS UNION” (Misspelled) | 10 | $500-$2,000+ |
| Major Cud (Large Blob on Washington) | 9 | $300-$1,500 |
| Double-Struck (Two Impressions) | 9 | $800-$2,500 |
| Extra Drumstick (3rd Stick) | 7 | $150-$500 |
| Weak/Missing Letters | 6 | $50-$300 |
Key Takeaway: The more obvious and unusual the error, the higher the value.
4. How to Sell Your Bicentennial Quarter Error (Step-by-Step)
Found a rare error? Here’s how to turn it into cash.
Step 1: Verify the Error
- Use a magnifying glass (or smartphone macro mode)
- Compare to verified error examples
- Post clear photos in coin forums (NGC or Reddit’s r/coins) for feedback
Step 2: Get It Graded (For High-Value Coins)
- PCGS or NGC grading adds credibility & value (cost: $30-$100)
- Ungraded coins can still sell but for lower prices
Step 3: Choose the Best Selling Method
| Platform | Best For | Pros & Cons |
|---|---|---|
| eBay | Rare errors, global buyers | High visibility  13% fees |
| Heritage Auctions | Ultra-rare coins | High bids Long process |
| Facebook Coin Groups | Quick sales | Low fees Scammers |
| Local Coin Shop | Fast cash | Immediate sale Low offers |
Step 4: Set the Right Price
- Check sold listings on eBay & Heritage Auctions
- For ungraded coins, start 10-20% higher to allow negotiation
5. Where to Sell for Maximum Profit
Best Online Marketplaces
- eBay – Best for competitive bidding
- GreatCollections – Best for certified coins
- Reddit (r/Coins4Sale) – Best for low fees
Best In-Person Options
- Coin Shows – Great for networking with collectors
- Local Coin Dealers – Fast but may lowball offers
Avoid: Pawn shops or “we buy coins” kiosks—they rarely pay fair value.
