The most exciting thing is you can find some of these rare, valuable pennies easily because they’re still in circulation. While a circulating coin typically lasts 30 to 40 years, some lucky collectors have found pennies minted in the mid-1900s in their pocket change. Of course, they’re worth more if they’re in better condition, and all circulating coins tend to have a lot of wear and tear.
These are the most valuable pennies in circulation. And they are worth a pretty penny if you find them.
15. 1995 Lincoln Memorial Cent (Doubled Die)
Penny Value: $54
*All of the coin values listed from 1958 or earlier and 1959 to 2000 came from USA Coin Book, unless otherwise noted.
Bottom Line: 1995 Lincoln Memorial Cent (Doubled Die)
The 1995 Double Die Obverse Lincoln Memorial Cent became a rare penny (and a valuable collector’s item) after a doubling error occurred.
In both the words “Liberty” and “In God We,” the letters are doubled.
Bottom Line: 1970 S Lincoln Memorial Cent (Small Date – High 7)
The 1970 Lincoln Memorial Cent is especially rare if it has a small letter “S” under the date, plus one more unique feature. The number “7” appears higher than usual, nearly level with the “0.”
This only takes place in the small date version.
13. 1999 S Lincoln Memorial Cent (Close AM)
Penny Value: $89
