Below is a simple guide to help you identify whether you have one of the rare copper-struck 1965 Lincoln pennies collectors are willing to pay hundreds for.
Why Certain 1965 Pennies Are Worth Hundreds
While most 1965 pennies are common zinc pieces, a handful were mistakenly struck using solid copper planchets. These copper versions stand out in color, weight, and value. For collectors, this unexpected mint error makes the coin a true prize. 
Key Differences: Common Zinc vs. Rare Copper 1965 Penny
| Feature | Common Zinc Penny | Rare Copper Penny |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | 2.5g  |
3.1g |
| Color | Dull brown  |
Bright red  |
| Value | 1¢ | $50 – $690  |
Pro Tip: Always start by checking the weight. It is the fastest and most reliable way to identify a rare copper-struck coin.
Step-by-Step: How To Identify a Valuable 1965 Penny
Step 1: Weigh the Coin
- 2.5g = standard zinc version
- 3.1g = rare copper error worth up to $690
Use a digital scale that measures to 0.01g for accuracy.
Step 2: Examine the Color
Color can reveal metal composition and approximate value.
| Color | Meaning | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Red |
Full copper | $100–$690 |
| Red-Brown |
Partial copper toning | $10–$50 |
| Brown |
Standard zinc | Face value |
Step 3: Look for Mint Errors
Some 1965 pennies feature collectible mistakes:
- Doubled dies: Doubling on LIBERTY or the date
- Off-center strikes: Misaligned designs can bring premiums
- Missing mintmarks: Sometimes desirable to collectors
1965 Penny Value Chart (By Grade)
| Grade | Red Copper Value | Red-Brown Value |
|---|---|---|
| MS-60 | $100 – $200 | $10 – $20 |
| MS-63 | $200 – $400 | $20 – $40 |
| MS-65 | $400 – $690 | $40 – $80 |
Higher-grade coins show stronger luster, cleaner surfaces, and sharper design details, which significantly raise their collector value.
Where You Can Still Find Rare 1965 Pennies
You don’t need to be a professional collector. Start here:
Bank rolls
Estate sales and flea markets
Inherited collections
Old change jars
Rare finds often turn up in the most ordinary places.
What To Do if You Find a Valuable Penny
Treat a rare penny with care — it could be worth hundreds.
Hold the coin only by the edges (gloves recommended)
Store it in a protective coin holder
Submit it to PCGS or NGC for grading
Consider selling through a reputable dealer or Heritage Auctions
Avoid These Costly Mistakes
- Do not clean the coin — this ruins the surface and can cut value in half.
- Avoid selling raw, ungraded coins — collectors pay far more for certified examples.
- Skip coin kiosks — you’ll get pennies on the dollar for rare pieces.
Start Your 1965 Penny Treasure Hunt
Your quick checklist:
Search your pocket change today
Weigh every 1965 penny you find
Share this guide with fellow collectors 
Final Thoughts
Who would have guessed that a simple 1965 penny could be worth up to $690? 
Before you spend that spare change, take a closer look. One of those old copper pennies could be your next collector jackpot. 
